Oral (Tribal), Scribal, and Typographical Cultures

Oral Scribal Typographical
rural

direct communication

sound & speech (voice & ear)

speaker & audience share space/ face-to-face

time limited and space bound

spontaneous

context-based

evanescent

fluid

community focused

no receptacle

uses circular mnemonic devices (recognized) to move forward

available to all members

passed down generations

collective memory flexible
tales based on myths

no survival

communication: outward

rural (monasteries) then urban (universities)

indirect communication

written down in an object

economy of scarcity

controlled by religion

may be sold but not as a business venture

monks worked for free and scribes are controlled by the universities

hand copied by a single person

1 copy = 1 text

image-focused

each object is unique

rare and expensive

beautiful and revered for its looks and manufacture

read, spoken, and heard 1 book= 1 reader = group of listeners

(sight, voice, and hearing) (read aloud to community)

available to few

owned by church institutions and read by clergy & elite

fixed text (with errors)

no space or punctuation

not time or space bound

locked up & guarded as high art

not concerned with reality & the world

favors intensive reading

few readers

permitted publication dictated by religious powers

text kept in monasteries or universities

texts memorized

collective memory dictated by religion

precarious survival

communication: upward

urban (large centers)

indirect communication

written down in an object

economy of abundance

capitalist venture

mass communication

1 copy = 1000s

machine-made identical copies

cheaper and more common

created an industry with a specialized workforce

commercial product fixed, corrected, and standardized

encourages the use of the vernacular and the standardization of Europe major languages

rise of dictionaries

adopts a more consistent page layout

new fonts

text-focused
utilitarian

small format, portable versions

allows for comparison and checking of facts

not time and space bound

may be read aloud to others

or in solitude and reflection

silent individual reading
(individualism & conformity)

favours sight

favors extensive reading

book may be owned by an individual

used by scholars to discuss reality & the world

data collected, compared and retrieved

made for an audience

literacy rate up and continues to increase

rise of popular reading culture

mass publication: ephemera (pamphlets, indulgences, short-term announcements)

broadly dissiminated

birth of marketing: agents, catalogues and stock lists

censored by state and church

texts consulted rather than memorized

collective memory fixed, recorded, and consulted

survival ensured by number of copies

communication: inward